HackerNews中文版

我知道这听起来可能有些负面，而且可能有点笼统，但……说真的，大型语言模型到底在帮你做什么，而不仅仅是纯粹的“节省时间”——也就是说，实际的、创新的工作。我个人觉得，虽然我无法证明，而且说实话也不想证明，但自去年十月左右以来，大型语言模型就被有意地“阉割”了。4.5-4.6 Opus…… 每家公司都故意或无意地（可能更糟）降低了它们的模型性能，它们无法承认这一点，如果你试图承认，它们还会对你进行煤气灯操控……但就我自己的实验而言，大型语言模型实际上比不用大型语言模型还要糟糕…… 我没有看到任何人构建出他们以前无法完成的东西……而且我看到很多不必要的东西被创造出来……以至于我记不起上次在这里看到的好主意是什么了（而以前每个月都会在这里看到很棒的想法）…… 我也无法再获得哪怕是中等水平的输出了……简直就是垃圾——字面意义上的“提示到垃圾桶”的流程…… Claude 是最差的。毫无疑问。自 4.5 版本以来，它们在每一个模型上都退步了……以至于 4.5 版本发布时，它无疑比今天市场上任何东西都好……价格却便宜得多……而且速度快了 10 到 100 倍…… 所以……我需要抽什么，哪种药能让我看到大型语言模型在工作？我需要“嗨起来”……因为 at this point……使用它们简直是侮辱…… Claude 会竭尽全力，想方设法避免做被要求的事情……然后会花 50 分钟思考……来生成一个简单的 HTML 网站……看起来像狗屎一样，而我用现成的样式手工编码可能只需要 90 分钟…… 所以……是的……什么药？多少？多久一次？副作用？

查看原文

I know this is going to sound negative, and probably a bit generalist but....seriously, what exactly is the LLM helping you with that is not just purely "time saving" - ie. Actual, novel work.I personally feel like while I cannot prove it, nor want to frankly, that LLMs have been neutered intentionally since around October of last year. 4.5-4.6 Opus....Every single company has degraded their models eirher intentionally or accidentally(probably worse) and they cannot admit it and will gaslight you if you even try to acknowledge it....but for my own experiments, LLMs are actually worse than no-LLM....I dont see anyone building anything they couldnt have done before hand....and I am seeing stuff that didnt need to be made...much more frequently....to the degree that I cannot remember the last good idea I have seen even on here (whereas there were cool ideas every month posted here)...I also cannot get even mediocre output anymore...Its literally just trash - Literally a prompt to dumpster pipeline....Clause is the worst. Hands down. They have regressed on every single model since 4.5....to rhe degree that 4.5 when it was released was hands down better than anythingg on the market today...for a fraction of the price....and was like 10-100x faster...So....what do I need to smoke, what drug makes me see the LLMs work? I need to get faded...because at this point....Its insulting to use them....Claude will literally bend over backwards to do everything in its power to avoid doing what was asked....and will take 50minutes of thinking....for a single html website....that looks like fucking dogwater and which I could have coded up by hand using off the shelf styling in probably 90 minutes....so...yeah...what drugs? How much? How often? Side effects?

大型语言模型。你事先抽了什么？