HN 读者请注意：人工智能实验室由缺乏世界制造业经验的人领导
1 分•作者: dzonga•2 个月前
我意识到，一些顶尖的美国“人工智能”实验室由缺乏制造专业知识的人领导，他们不了解现实世界中事物的制造过程。我并非质疑他们作为世界级研究人员的经验，但研究实验室并非真实世界，真实世界有着复杂的动态。
他们所有的“模型”都是在寻找问题。但这并不意味着这些模型对某些任务没有用处。
在发布模型之前，他们从未停下来问——我们正在朝着什么目标努力，或者我们在解决什么问题。因此出现了无意义的基准测试。
这让我想起一句名言：“如果你不了解一个过程，你就什么都不懂。”
即使他们现在提出的“人工智能”能够编写软件，也表明他们认为软件就是代码行或功能。他们忘记了软件是来自一或多个个体就世界观进行沟通/妥协的复杂/简单过程的结果。
而 Yann LeCun 可能是“人工智能”领域唯一一个真正了解现实世界的人。
查看原文
I have realized - some of the premier american 'a.i' labs are headed by people without manufacturing expertise - of | or how things are made in the real world. I'm not doubting their experience as world class researchers - but the research lab is not the real world - with complex dynamics.<p>all their 'models' are solutions seeking problems. but it doesn't mean the models are not useful for some tasks.<p>before releasing models - they have never stopped to ask - what are we working towards or what are we solving. hence the nonsense benchmarks.<p>it reminds me of a certain quote "if you don't understand a process, you don't know shit".<p>even what they propose as 'a.i' now writes software - shows they think software == lines of code or features. forgetting software is the result out of complicated/simple process of 1 or more individuals talking/compromising on a world view.<p>& probably the only person in 'a.i' who has grip on the world in Yann LeCun.