Ask HN：你在 Product Hunt 上注意到过令人信服的 AI 评论吗？
1 分•作者: loptic_tyasuda•3 个月前
几天前，我第一次在 Product Hunt 上发布了我的工具。虽然排名不高，但我收到了四条评论和一些点赞。我感到一种微小但真实的成就感。
我很自然地认真回复了每一条评论。
然而，后来我很好奇是谁留下了这些评论，于是点击了他们的 X（推特）个人资料链接。我被我发现的景象惊呆了……在这四个账号中，有两个被封禁了，另外两个是在过去三个月内创建的，没有任何帖子。
请注意，以下内容仅为我的猜测。
对我来说，他们的评论感觉完全自然。它们与我的工具描述非常契合，其中一个甚至提出了一个真正有用的功能建议。
但当我仔细检查措辞时，我意识到这些短语符合现代大型语言模型（LLM）的典型输出模式——那种礼貌、清晰、结构良好的评论模板。他们很可能是机器人。
当然，我不能肯定地说他们是 AI 机器人。
其他人是否在 Product Hunt 或其他发布平台上遇到过类似的情况？我很想听听你们的经历。
查看原文
A few days ago, I launched my tool on Product Hunt for the first time. Although it didn't rank high, I received four comments and a few upvotes. I felt a small but genuine sense of accomplishment.
Naturally, I replied to each comment with care.
However, I later got curious about who left those comments and clicked on their X (Twitter) profile links. I was shocked by what I found... out of the four accounts, two were banned, and the other two were created within the last three months with zero posts.
Please note that what follows is just my speculation.
To me, their comments felt completely natural. They aligned well with my tool's description, and one even offered a genuinely useful feature suggestion.
But when I carefully re-examined the wording, I realized the phrases fit the typical output pattern of modern LLMs—that polite, articulate, and well-structured review template. They were very likely bots.
Of course, I cannot say for certain that they were AI bots.
Has anyone else experienced something similar on Product Hunt or other launch platforms? I'd love to hear your experiences.