HackerNews中文版

我注意到这个令人不安的趋势已经有一段时间了。我所说的高 karma 指的是远超 1000 karma 的用户。其中一些用户的评论非常奇怪，我找不到任何善意的解释。除非他们可能跳过了每隔一个词来阅读，或者别的什么……然后回应一个虚构的父评论。不客气地说，他们可能是半随机地敲击键盘、胡言乱语、情绪失控等等。或者是由大型语言模型（LLM）生成的……除了风格不匹配。当然，这种情况对于低 karma 用户来说一直很普遍，但现在它正逐渐蔓延到更高的 karma 用户中。例如，我最近就遇到了一个奇怪的经历。我仔细检查了谷歌搜索结果的前 10 页，关于我在评论链中之前提到的一个说法，并提到它似乎支持我的说法。也许有人这样做的新鲜感，而不是随意发表意见，触发了什么。现实地说，这并没有花费超过 5 分钟的精力，但仍然……这应该是 1 到 5 分钟的真实努力。过了一会儿，一个奇怪的回复来了，指责我“毫不费力”，等等。如果这是一个高强度的回复，这可能说得通……但这是一个匆忙写成的简短回复……显然只花费了不到一分钟的真实精力。指责我“毫不费力”，要求我付出比他们更多的努力，然后他们自己却“毫不费力”……这造成了一个坦率地说毫无意义的回复。在我指出之后，如果他们也花费了“毫不费力”，那么根据定义，我已经付出了更多，或者同等的努力……没有人回应。当然，我的评论被标记了，而他们的评论却获得了点赞…… 其他人是否遇到过类似的情况，或者思考过这个问题向上蔓延？

查看原文

I’ve been noticing this disturbing trend for quite a while. By high karma I mean well over 1000 karma.And some of these leave comments so bizarre, that I can’t find any charitable explanation.Other than perhaps they may be skipping reading every other word or something… and then respond to an imaginary version of the parent.Uncharitably, they could be semi-random keyboard bashing, deranged bashing, emotional tantrums, and so on. Or LLM written… except the style doesnt match.Of course this has always been somewhat prevalent for low karma users, but it’s now creeping up higher and higher.For example, I had a recent bizarre encounter.I had double checked the first 10 pages of google results, in regards to a claim that I implied prior in the comment chain, mentioning that it seemed supportive of the claim.Maybe the novelty of someone doing that, and not just randomly opining, triggered something.Realistically, it didn’t take more than 5 minutes of effort, but still… it would have been 1 to 5 minutes of genuine effort.A bit later, a bizarre reply came making the accusation that I had put in “no effort”, and so on.Which might have made sense in a high effort reply… except it was a hastily written short reply… that obviously took under a minute of genuine effort.Accusing me of “no effort”, asking me to put in more effort than them, and then themselves putting in “no effort”… created a frankly nonsensical reply.After pointing it out, that if they spent “no effort” too, I would have already put in more, or equal, effort by definition… there was no response from anyone.Of course my comments were flagged and theirs was upvoted…Has anyone else encountered similar or thought about this issue spreading upwards?

为什么 HN 上有越来越多的完全不理智的高积分用户？