Ask HN：你最喜欢的唱片里留下的制作失误是什么？
1 分•作者: vinylcast•2 个月前
为一个小型的独立项目研究已记录的案例。经典案例包括：
* 平克·弗洛伊德乐队的《Money》中出现的咳嗽声（罗杰·沃特斯）
* 齐柏林飞艇乐队的《The Song Remains the Same》中，约翰·博纳姆的踩镲掉落，他们保留了数拍
* 金属乐队的《Master of Puppets》中，克里夫·伯顿的贝斯音色在某一部分略微失相
* 《Helter Skelter》中的“我的手指起了水泡！”（仅单声道混音版）
还有哪些错误被记录下来（《Mojo》杂志、《滚石》杂志、传记、工程师采访），最终对专辑的影响超出了制作人的预期？特别感兴趣的是工程师/制作人实际在录音中说过“我们保留了这个，因为{具体原因}”的案例，而不是粉丝们的猜测。
查看原文
Researching documented cases for a small independent project. The classics:
- The cough on Pink Floyd's 'Money' (Roger Waters)
- John Bonham's hi-hat dropping on 'The Song Remains the Same', they kept the count-in
- Cliff Burton's bass tone on 'Master of Puppets' being slightly out of phase on one section
- 'I've got blisters on my fingers!' on Helter Skelter (mono mix only)<p>What other mistakes are documented (Mojo, Rolling Stone, biography, engineer interview) that ended up shaping the album more than the producer planned? Especially interested in cases where the engineer / producer has actually said on record 'we kept this in because of {specific reason}' rather than fan theories.