Ask HN: Claude Code 在被问到“我们应该放弃吗?”之后,对你来说成功了吗?

2作者: webwielder23 天前
几乎每次 Claude 没能正确实现某个功能或多次修复一个错误时,如果我问“我们放弃吗?”它都会声明它不会放弃,然后成功完成任务。当然,这很可能仅仅是因为我采取这种方式时,恰好赶上了 Claude 在解决问题上的进展,但缺乏严谨的测试,这种现象确实令人难以置信。我无法决定是该为我拥有一个“胜利”按钮而高兴,还是对“不得不”经历这个仪式而感到恼火。
查看原文
Almost every time Claude has failed to properly implement something or fix a bug several times, if I ask "should we give up?" it declares it's not giving up and successfully completes the task. Of course, it could very well be that when I resort to this tends to coincide with Claude's progress on a problem, but absent rigorous testing, it's truly uncanny. I can't decide whether to be happy I have a "win" button or exasperated that I "have" to go through the ritual.