HackerNews中文版

我无法举出一个由人工智能提出的软件应用或软件功能的例子。一个都没有。以 Excel 为例。人工智能不仅未能完全取代 Excel，也未能取代它的任何功能。人工智能仅仅以智能聊天机器人的形式被添加为一个附加功能。整个行业都是这种趋势，这也是为什么人工智能未能从根本上改变我们现有的任何软件应用的原因。<p>你可能会问：那么 AI 原生应用呢？事实证明，它们中的大多数本质上是现有软件的克隆，只是在顶部添加了一个聊天机器人。由于人工智能容易出错的特性，任何利用它的应用程序也必须提供所有用于覆盖其所有决策的控件。所以，最终你得到的是一个传统的软件应用加上人工智能。<p>人工智能曾承诺要改变甚至取代软件应用，但它所做的只是用一个不可靠的聊天机器人来增强它们。所有旧的字段和按钮仍然存在，但现在多了一个你可以输入文本并寄希望于结果的文本框。

查看原文

I can’t name a single software application or software feature that has been mooted by AI. Zero. Take Excel as an example. Not only has AI failed to replace Excel in its entirety, but it has also failed to replace any of its features. AI was simply appended as an additional feature in the form of an agentic chatbot. This has been the trend across the entire industry, and it’s why AI has failed to fundamentally transform any of our exiting software application.<p>Now you might ask: what about AI native applications? Well, as it turns out, most of them are essentially clones of existing software but with a chatbot slapped on top. Because of the error prone nature of AI, any application that leverages it also has to surface all of the controls required to override all of its decisions. So you end up with a traditional software application plus AI.<p>AI promised to transform and even replace software applications, but all it did instead was augment them with an unreliable chatbot. All of the old fields and buttons are still there, but now there’s an additional text field that you can type into and hope for the best.

人工智能（AI）尚未取代任何一个软件应用或功能。