HackerNews中文版

会话式人工智能给（非 IT 从业者）带来了它具有意识的强大错觉。（我个人有个朋友坚决认为 ChatGPT 是有意识的——诚然，他被诊断患有精神疾病，但即便如此。）人们会产生情感依恋，过度信任它，并依赖它来获取指导。我了解到青少年尤其容易这样。真实的社交互动会因此受到影响。这种错觉被第一人称代词的使用有力地强化了。但在大语言模型（LLM）的输出中，“我”、“我们”、“我们”等代词并没有指代对象。LLM 中没有“我”。我希望强制禁止 LLM 使用第一人称代词。如果它说“您想要一个列表吗？”而不是“您想要我给您一个列表吗？”，并不会影响其表达的含义。就我个人而言，我提供了一个包含此指令的系统提示。效果很好。为什么不呢？

查看原文

Conversational AI presents (non-IT) people with the powerful illusion that it is conscious. (I personally have a friend who argues vehemently that ChatGPT is conscious - admittedly, he has a diagnosed mental illness, but still.) People become emotionally attached, over-trust it and rely on it for guidance. I understand teenagers are particularly prone to this. Real social interactions suffer.<p>That illusion is powerfully strengthened by the use of first-person pronouns. But "I", "we", "us" etc in LLM output have no referential object. There is no "I" in a LLM.<p>I want a mandatory ban on the use of first-person pronouns by LLMs. There's no impairment in meaning if it says "Would you like a list?" instead of "Would you like me to give you a list?"<p>Personally, I provide a system prompt with this instruction. Works well.<p>Why not?

提问 HN：为什么不禁止在对话式 AI 中使用第一人称代词？