提问 HN：当新用户提交的内容消失时会发生什么？
1 分•作者: ursAxZA•1 天前
我的账号创建于 8 天前，今天早些时候提交了一个链接。
起初的几个小时，一切看起来都很正常——讨论页面存在，提交内容也出现在我的个人资料中。
几个小时后，讨论页面消失了。
当我注销登录时，提交内容也从我的个人资料中完全消失了。
没有出现“已删除”标记或审核通知——它就这么凭空消失了。
—— ─── ─── ───
另外，当我登录时，我仍然可以看到我提交的全部五个内容，但当我注销登录时，只剩下四个。消失的那个正是那个链接。如果这只是我这边的一个显示问题，其他人仍然可以看到它，我提前道歉——我可能只是误解了新用户提交内容的表现方式。
帖子本身是无害的（一篇关于一种可视化方法，帮助孩子们理解乘法的教育文章），所以我试图弄清楚这对于新账号来说是正常行为，还是表明提交内容被自动过滤了。
───────── ─── ─── ─── ─────────
所以我想问：
• 低声望的新账号提交内容被悄无声息地过滤掉是常见现象吗？
• 某些标题或帖子格式会触发自动删除吗？
• 我是否在不知情的情况下违反了某项规定？
以及相关问题：
• 稍后用不同的标题重新发布可以接受吗？
• 或者作为新用户，有没有推荐的方法来避免触发过滤器？
• 这种类型的帖子作为“Show HN”会更好吗？
───────── ─── ─── ─── ─────────
我不是想刷声望——只是想了解 HN 如何处理新用户的提交内容，这样我就能避免重复同样的错误。
如果这是预期的行为，我很乐意了解其背后的启发式算法。
如果这个问题本身违反了任何规范，请告诉我——我还在学习 HN 的运作方式。
谢谢。
查看原文
My account is 8 days old and I submitted a link earlier today.
For the first few hours everything looked normal at first — the discussion page existed, and the submission appeared in my profile.<p>A few hours later, the discussion page disappeared.
When I log out, the submission no longer appears in my profile at all.
There was no “dead” flag or moderation notice — it simply vanished.<p>─── ─── ───<p>Also, when I’m logged in I still see all five of my submissions, but when I log out only four appear. The missing one is exactly the link that disappeared. If this is just a display quirk on my side and others can still see it, apologies in advance — I may simply be misunderstanding how submissions behave for new users.<p>The post itself was harmless (an educational piece about a visualization method for helping children understand multiplication), so I’m trying to figure out whether this is normal behavior for new accounts or a sign that the submission was auto-filtered.<p>───────── ─── ─── ─── ─────────<p>So I’d like to ask:<p>• Is it common for low-karma, new accounts to have submissions silently filtered out?
• Do certain titles or post formats trigger automated removal?
• Could I have unknowingly violated a guideline?<p>And related to that:<p>• Is it acceptable to repost later with a different title?
• Or is there a recommended way to avoid triggering filters as a new user?
• Would this type of post have been better as a “Show HN”?<p>───────── ─── ─── ─── ─────────<p>I’m not trying to game karma — just trying to understand how HN handles new-user submissions so I can avoid repeating the same mistake.
If this is expected behavior, I’d appreciate any insight into the underlying heuristics.<p>If this question itself violates any norms, please let me know — I’m still learning how HN works.<p>Thanks.