GPT-5 不给力？
1 分•作者: anupshinde•9 个月前
总结 - 我一直在努力让 GPT-5 稳定地“合拍”。
我不知道 GPT-5（在 ChatGPT.com 上）出了什么问题。表面上看，一切都很好，但当你深入了解细节时，就会发现问题。
有时候它太聪明，有时候又很愚蠢。这一切都发生在同一个聊天会话中。
有时候它会犯错，有时候又不会。
有时候它会记住上下文，有时候它会忘记，需要多次提醒。
对于代码 - 它会编写更简单的代码或更复杂的代码 - 有缺陷的代码或可运行的代码 - 并且很难预测它何时会做什么。
问题通常有多种解决方案。而 GPT-5 似乎也遵循这一原则。 即使给它同一个问题两次，它也会给出不同的解决方案。但并不能每次都可靠地做到这一点。
与 Claude 模型或 GPT-4o 相比，使用它（或与它“合拍”）变得相当困难。
GPT-4o 模型并没有更好 - 但至少它很可靠。它的行为有一种微妙的模式。
我知道它什么时候会起作用，会犯什么错误，以及如何让它工作，以及什么时候它不会起作用。
而且在写作时，GPT-4o 通常听起来像一位哲学家诗人。
首先，GPT-5 在炒作发布后令人失望。现在又这样。
这种体验主要基于 ChatGPT，以及 GitHub Copilot 的一点点。对于 Copilot，我坚持使用 Claude Sonnet 4。
Canvas 感觉也很 buggy。当你让它编辑文本的一部分时，它有时也会删除其他部分。尽管我不太使用 Canvas。
我以为这可能是由于自动路由造成的。并尝试通过选择 GPT-5 类型来修复它，但没有成功。
还有其他人遇到过同样的问题吗？你们是如何解决的？
查看原文
TL;DR - I have been struggling with GPT-5 to get it to 'vibe' reliably.<p>I don't know what's wrong with GPT-5 (on ChatGPT.com). On the surface, everything looks hunky-dory until you get into the details.<p>Sometimes it is too smart, and sometimes it is stupid. All this within the same chat-session.
Sometimes it makes mistakes, other times it does not.
Sometimes it remembers the context, sometimes it forgets and has to be reminded multiple times.
With code - it writes easier code or complex code - buggy code or working code - and it is hard to predict when it would do what.<p>Problems often have multiple solutions. And GPT-5 seems to adhere to that philosophy. Given it the same problem twice, it will come up with different solutions. But not reliably do so every time.<p>It has become quite difficult to use it (or 'vibe' with it) - compared to Claude models or GPT-4o.<p>The GPT-4o model was not better - but at least it was reliable. There was a subtle pattern to its behavior.
I knew when it would work, what mistake it would make, and how to get it to work, and when it would not work.
And when writing, GPT-4o would usually sound like a philosophical poet.<p>First, GPT-5 disappointed after the hyped launch. And now this.<p>This experience is mostly based on ChatGPT, and a bit on GitHub Copilot. With Copilot, I stick to Claude Sonnet 4.<p>The Canvas also feels buggy. When you ask it to edit a part of the text, it sometimes deletes other sections as well. Albeit, I do not use Canvas as much.<p>I thought it may be due to auto-routing. And tried to fix it by selecting the GPT-5 type, no luck.<p>Has anybody else faced the same problem? And how did you resolve it?