Ask HN: 氛围编程（vibe coding）在实际工作中或运营产品/服务中可行吗？
2 分•作者: haebom•5 个月前
我到处都在看到对“氛围编程”的赞扬，所以我也亲自尝试了几次。虽然它对简单的脚本或原型有效，但当复杂性增加或需要更实质性的东西时，它似乎会遇到明显的局限性。是我遗漏了什么吗？我很想听听你们的经验。
作为背景，我的尝试在简单的自动化任务和快速原型方面是成功的，但当我试图构建更复杂的系统或任何需要强大的错误处理、可维护性或与现有代码库集成的东西时，这种方法就显得力不从心了。生成的代码通常缺乏生产系统所需的架构考虑和边缘情况处理。
有人成功地将这种方法用于严肃的开发工作吗，或者它主要是一个用于快速原型设计和学习的工具？您在扩展 AI 辅助编码以超越简单任务方面的经验是什么？
查看原文
I keep seeing praise for vibe coding everywhere, so I’ve tried it myself a few times. While it works fine for simple scripts or mockups, it seems to hit clear limitations when complexity increases or when you need something more substantial. Am I missing something here? I’d love to hear your experiences.
For context, my attempts have been successful with straightforward automation tasks and quick prototypes, but when I’ve tried to build more complex systems or anything requiring robust error handling, maintainability, or integration with existing codebases, the approach falls short. The generated code often lacks the architectural considerations and edge case handling that production systems require.
Has anyone successfully used this approach for serious development work, or is it primarily a tool for rapid prototyping and learning? What’s been your experience with scaling AI-assisted coding beyond simple tasks?